ECHL: Adam Scheel Stifles Toledo Walleye Again, Take 2-0 Lead in the Western Conference Finals

ECHL/ Idaho Steelheads

Sunday afternoon’s tilt between the Idaho Steelheads and the Toledo Walleye looked similar to game one from Saturday night. Both teams got their fair share of chances, but Adam Scheel and John Lethemon stood tall for the Steelheads and Walleye, respectively. Lethemon, who won the Goaltender of the Year Award, got his first start of the series as Sebastian Cossa took the loss in Game 1. Scheel was back in net after shutting out the high-powered Walleye offense in Game 1. Scheel has not given up a goal since the 14:36 mark of Game 4 in the Division Finals, and his shutout streak is at 185:24, and he’s just 14:25 from breaking Travis Scott’s record of 199:59 set in 1999.

My pre-series prediction of a quick five-game series win for the Walleye is no longer possible. Toledo had been hot coming into the WCF, winning both previous series without surrendering any losses. Scheel had been a shell of himself from the regular season, where he was All-ECHL 2nd Team. Scheel had given up 31 goals in the two previous series, which is 3rd worst among playoff goalies.

Game 2 was tight, with no scoring until Wade Murphy took a pass from Jade Miller after getting out of the penalty box and was in on a breakaway. Lethemon would deny him, but Murphy would collect the puck from the corner, and wrist one passed Lethemon at 17:54 of the 1st period.

No other goals would be scored in the remainder of the period as Idaho continued the trend of not letting Toledo outshoot them. The Steelheads would win that battle 21-12.

The 2nd period would bring more of the same, where both teams would have some early chances, but no goals would be scored early in the period. Idaho would break through again when they broke out of their zone, and Ryan Dmowski fed a wide-open Justin Ducharme, and he beat Lethemon on the backhand to give the Steelheads a 2-0 lead. The goal was Ducharme’s 3rd of the playoffs. The 2nd would end like the first period, with no other goals being scored. Idaho won the shots on goal, outpacing Toledo 11-8.

Lethemon hasn’t played badly in the game, and the rest of the Walleye have got some good chances on net, but the Walleye have not been able to solve Scheel. The Walleye also had their chances on the power play but have gone cold at the wrong time, going 0/2 with the extra skater.

The 3rd period also mirrored the 3rd period of Game 1. Idaho played defense well enough to limit Toledo’s chances while holding the two-goal lead. Scheel still had to make some good saves to conserve the shutout. Toledo committed an interference penalty at 15:36 of the period, and Idaho made them pay for it when Colton Kehler put the game on ice with his fourth goal of the playoffs on the power play. Kehlr made a great move to get low near the goal and received a pass from Pelton-Byce to beat Lethemon.

Toledo can take some pride in winning the shots-on-goal battle for the first time in the series in the 3rd period with a 13-6 tally. Game 3 will take place on Wednesday night in Toldeo. The Walleye will host the next three games in a row if the series goes that far. Games 6 and 7 will take place in Idaho if needed.


Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Phil Wilds

Atlanta Gladiators writer for Inside The Rink. Patiently waiting for the 3rd Atlanta NHL team! Follow me on Twitter @PWilds121 for awful takes that you will most certainly disagree with!

Leave a Reply

PHOTOS: Adirondack Thunder vs. Maine Mariners – 03/22/2025

PORTLAND, Maine. – The Adirondack Thunder erased a two-goal deficit by putting up four unanswered goals on Saturday, securing a 4-3 win over the Maine Mariners. Adirondack’s first goal of the game came at 2:37 in the second period from Kaleb Ergang, who snuck a slap shot by the glove side of Maine’s goaltender Brad Arvanitis. […]

Read More

PHOTOS: Norfolk Admirals vs. Reading Royals – 03/22/2025

READING, Pa. – The Reading Royals faced off against the Norfolk Admirals Saturday night at Santander Arena. The Royals were rebranded for the night as the Pretzel City Royals. The Admirals defeated the Royals 4-1. Check out this photo gallery from Inside the Rink’s Sarah Pietrowski who was there to capture the action.

Read More

PHOTOS: Greenville Swamp Rabbits vs. South Carolina Stingrays – 03/21/2025

NORTH CHARLESTON, S.C. – The South Carolina Stingrays won their ninth consecutive game, beating the Greenville Swamp Rabbits 5-1 at the North Charleston Coliseum in front of 5,644 fans on Friday night. Charlie Combs, Micah Miller (2), Dean Loukus, and Tyler Weiss all scored for the Stingrays. The team’s goaltender, Seth Eisele, made an impressive 30 saves […]

Read More