I’ve wondered for several years whether top prospects showcases matter and if they make a difference in players’ draft stock or improve performance. The new CHL-USA Prospects Challenge could finally give us answers, and maybe even change the junior hockey landscape across Canada and the U.S.
It’s a massive step in how two hockey powerhouses, the CHL (Canadian Hockey League) and USA Hockey, are starting to collaborate. Historically, these organizations have been rivals, scrapping for talent and spearheading the tension between Hockey Canada and USA Hockey. But times are changing. The NCAA’s decision to allow CHL players to keep their College Hockey eligibility has forced both sides to rethink their recruiting strategies, especially the USHL, who lost their significant advantage.
The first of at least three annual CHL-USA Prospects Challenges, featuring games in London, Ontario on Tuesday and Oshawa on Wednesday, is a step towards uniting the two parties. The partnership also started before the NCAA’s rule change, proving it is forward-thinking. USHL Commissioner Glen Heffernan recently stated he’s open to a merger down the road, and the bosses of the OHL, QMJHL, and WHL love the idea, even inviting him to the Memorial Cup last year. There’s much work to do, but both sides see the bigger picture and want to strengthen junior hockey for all parties involved.
The tilts pit the CHL’s top 2025 NHL draft-eligible players against the USNTDP U18 squad. A point system will decide the series winner with a 20-minute, 3-on-3 overtime period if it ends in a tie.
On paper, Team CHL is lethal. They have 15 players with “A” ratings from NHL Central Scouting, including projected No. 2 overall pick and OHL Brampton Steelheads center Porter Martone, WHL Prince George’s netminder Joshua Ravensbergen, and standout OHL Erie Otters blueliner Matthew Schaefer. Yet, although they’re weaker, team USA compensates with the advantage of chemistry. The roster has been playing together for two years, which could help them punch above their weight against the Canadian’s raw talent.
The future of hockey development hinges on how well organizations like the CHL and USA Hockey can adapt. Both must be good stewards of the sport and seek a merger. This series proves progress is possible and could be the start of changing how fans evaluate prospects forever. In the meantime, we’ve always wondered who’s better, the CHL or the USHL. We’re about to find out.
