NHL Implements New Coach’s Challenge Rule

Graphic Credit: Jake Farmer/InsideTheRink

As the 2024-25 season is less than a month away, the National Hockey League announced a series of rule changes that will be implemented. Coaches’ challenges have been a big topic in the last several seasons ever since they were first implemented. But as the game is getting faster and faster, with better technologies and camera angles, the league has to keep up with the times.

Ever hate it when the officials call a puck-over-glass penalty, and it clearly wasn’t a penalty? Well, it’s now challengeable, effective next season. Coaches from the bench can now wave to challenge delay of game penalties that come their way and force a video review by the referees and the situation room in Toronto.

According to Scouting The Refs, this is the first instance of a coach’s challenge affecting penalties, and is a big step in the right direction regarding challenges. With so many camera angles and resources to spare in one of the biggest leagues in the world, it’s a no-brainer to implement this rule. But fans are skeptical of it. Perhaps it’ll be another one of those offsides reviews that take so long to determine its precise ruling (2016, The Guardian).

Now, can a team challenge a delay of game penalty if the officials deem it not a penalty? No, the penalty must be originally called by the officials in order for it to be challengeable. In other words, the officials have the prerogative to make the initial decision before the coaches can have a decision. So, what’s the penalty for losing the challenge? Well, like all failed video-review challenges, the defending team will be assessed a minor penalty for delay of game.

However, since the team is technically challenging a penalty, they will be assessed the original two-minute minor plus an additional two minutes — effectively making it a four-minute double-minor penalty that will be five-on-four. The challenge comes with a hefty price, and it’s up to the individual team’s video coaches to get it right before initiating the challenge.

The NHL Official Rule Book Description

When a minor penalty for delaying the game has been assessed under Rule 63.2 (iii) for shooting or batting the puck out of play from the defending zone. This will only apply to delay of game penalties when the shot/batted puck is determined to have subsequently deflected off a player, stick, glass or boards, etc., and not a judgment call.

The standard for overturning a minor penalty for delaying the game – puck over glass call to a defending player is the NHL Situation Room, after reviewing all replays and consulting with the On-Ice Official(s), determines that the puck was deflected or rebounded off the boards, glass, goal net frame or otherwise, or did not break the plane of the glass directed upwards, and should not be subject to a minor penalty (38.12).

No challenge can be issued for a non-call, in other words, no challenge is to be considered when the On-Ice Officials deem that it was not a violation of Rule 63.2 (iii). A challenge can only be used to rescind a penalty, not to have one assessed.

In the event of a failed challenge, an additional minor penalty (or double-minor penalty, as appropriate in cases where teams have already been penalized for an unsuccessful challenge in the game) will be assessed in addition to the existing delay of game penalty.

ITR 47: Then There Was Nothing Inside The Rink

Join Conrad and Chris as the discuss Gavin McKenna making the jump to the NCAA, Pittsburgh and San Jose making additions, and the NHL season to begin on October 7, 2025.
  1. ITR 47: Then There Was Nothing
  2. ITR 46: Offseason Chaos
  3. ITR 45: Everything Is Happening
  4. ITR 44: We Have A Champion…Again
  5. ITR 43: It's Winning Time

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Jake Farmer

I'm a photographer and writer covering the ECHL Greenville Swamp Rabbits based in Greenville, South Carolina, and writer of Tampa Bay Lightning content. Twitter and Instagram: JakeCF.Hockey

Leave a Reply

New York Rangers

Opinion: Why Rangers’ Zibanejad Will Return to Form This Upcoming Season

Last season was a rough one for New York Rangers forward Mika Zibanejad. For starters, his production was not what it should have been for someone who is being paid to be the team’s number one center. Zibanejad, 32, had 62 points (20 goals and 42 assists) while playing in all 82 games last season. […]

Read More
Detroit Red Wings

How do the Red Wings Stack Up Against the Rest of the NHL

Detroit has been criticized for its slow pace of improvement while attempting to return to the playoffs. Further critiques among fans will involve their holes at the top line left-wing and first pair left defense (or second pair right defense, depending on how you look at the lineup card). So with that, let’s take a […]

Read More
Kyle Connor skating for the Winnipeg Jets

Winnipeg Jets 2025-26 Season Preview

The Winnipeg Jets enter the 2025-26 season with the weight of expectations completely on their shoulders. After winning the Presidents’ Trophy last season with 116 points and dominating stretches of regular-season play, the Jets’ year ended abruptly in the conference semifinals at the hands of the Dallas Stars. That sting has lingered all summer, and […]

Read More