NHL Playoffs: Who Should the Edmonton Oilers Start in Net in Game 5?

Calvin Pickard in net during Game 4 of Oilers vs. Canucls in the 2024 Stanley Cup Playoffs
Photo: Kevin Neufeld | Inside The Rink

In his first-ever Stanley Cup Playoff start, Calvin Pickard led the Edmonton Oilers to a 3-2 win over the Vancouver Canucks, evening the series at 2-2 on Tuesday night. The sold-out Rogers Place rallied behind him throughout the game, and he consistently made crucial saves despite heavy traffic in front of the net. Although two unfortunate goals slipped past Pickard due to traffic and deflections, he otherwise stood strong, stopping 19 out of 21 shots with a 0.905 SV%. Head Coach Kris Knoblauch faces a significant decision ahead of Game 5 in Vancouver on Thursday night – will the struggling Stuart Skinner or Calvin Pickard get the nod as the starter?

I believe that Calvin Pickard should start for the second game in a row on Thursday night. Stuart Skinner has been struggling, allowing an alarming 12 goals in just three games with a 0.793 save % in the series against Vancouver. Given these statistics, it seems to be a wise decision for Edmonton’s Head Coach, Kris Knoblauch, to give Pickard another opportunity to defend the net. Although Skinner has the potential to bounce back, I would opt to continue riding the hot streak with a goalie who recently secured his first NHL Playoff win and demonstrated a solid performance in Game 4. It’s also important to note that numerous backup goalies have effectively led their teams deep into later rounds in the playoffs, as exemplified by Adin Hill’s performance for the Vegas Golden Knights last year. While Knoblauch may consider using Skinner in subsequent games, it is my belief that Pickard should unquestionably start Game 5.

Calvin Pickard post-game interview

ITR 34: End Of The Road Inside The Rink

 Join Conrad and Chris as they discuss the Boston Bruins front office, Logan Couture's retirement, Edmonton Oilers Injuries leading into the playoffs, and playoff matchups! 
  1. ITR 34: End Of The Road
  2. ITR 33: The Gr8 One
  3. ITR 32: The Final Countdown
  4. ITR 31: Let Them Fight
  5. ITR 30: Down The Stretch

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Matthew Buhrmann

Covering Cincinnati Cyclones l Student @uofcincy l @Mbuhrmann61 on X

Leave a Reply

Pittsburgh Penguins

Rust’s Double Downs Capitals In Pens’ Season Finale

The conclusive blare of the final horn resonated through PPG Paints Arena on Thursday night, bringing the curtain down on a season of unfulfilled promise for the playoff-less Penguins, who nonetheless delivered a parting shot by defeating their rivals, the Washington Capitals, 5-2. While this victory offered a momentary high for the Penguins, its true […]

Read More

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Winnipeg Jets vs St. Louis Blues Series Preview

One more sleep and the Winnipeg Jets and St. Louis Blues battle it out for the first time since 2019 in the postseason. Both teams have a close head-to-head rivalry since the 1999-2000 season, but have only met once in the playoffs. A throwback to the clash in 2019 has shades of the past after […]

Read More

The Connor McDavid Lottery, 10 Years Later

When you have a job writing about the Edmonton Oilers, it’s hard not to type out his name at least once in every article. April 18th, 2015, the 9th year in our team’s Decade of Darkness had just come to a close, finishing 3rd last league-wide. Connor McDavid was the projected top prospect in that year’s […]

Read More