NY Rangers Recap: Rangers Fall To Gibson, Ducks, and Bad Puck Luck

Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

Perhaps we should have known the Rangers were in trouble when it was repeatedly pointed out that the Anaheim Ducks had not yet won in regulation. That is no longer true. 

The NY Rangers lost to the Anaheim Ducks last night 3-2 without any need for overtime. This game mirrored many of the frustrating trends that have (maybe plagued is too strong a word) but certainly contributed to the Rangers’ stop-and-go season so far.  

It wasn’t for lack of effort or offensive pressure. This was another game the Rangers had 40+ shots (outshot the Ducks 43-22) and several phases where they seemed to live in Anaheim’s zone. Yet, they were repeatedly stymied by a combination of good goaltending, lack of finishing, and the bizarre tease of pucks ringing off posts/crossbars at a frequency I can’t ever remember seeing before for this long of a stretch. 

 It also didn’t help that the power play went 0 for 4 (an abbreviated 4th PP but still) against the league’s worst penalty kill. When that happens, and you factor in the team’s 5×5 inconsistency, you get last night’s result. 

The game started fine for the Blueshirts as it was clear this wide-open style, with room to move, is one they feel comfortable in. Ironically enough, a tremendous individual effort with a player creating his own space led to the first goal. Barclay Goodrow made a fine defensive play, fought off a defender while streaking to the net, and squeaked the puck by Gibson for a 1-0 lead. It was an impressive display of skill for a skater not known for his dynamic prowess. 

Unfortunately for the Rangers, they gave the lead right back as the Ducks scored 31 seconds later when Mason McTavish got one by Halak. This is another one of those frustrating trends in the early going of this season, where the team scuttles any momentum by immediately letting the opponent score or draw a penalty right after a goal.  

It was 1-1 after one, but the vibe still felt positive for New York. That feeling quickly dissipated, though, 39 seconds into the period. Dmitry Kulikov, a player that had a scary moment in the 1st getting hit in the face with the puck, sent an innocent-looking shot toward Halak that somehow got through his blocker. It was as bad a goal as it gets, and it certainly seemed to deflate the team. 

Sure enough, five minutes later, Troy Terry scored by roofing one past Halak, and in a blink, the Rangers were staring at a two-goal deficit.  

To the Rangers’ credit, it wasn’t much later that they began to control the flow of the game. Anaheim had their moments, but for the most part, the Rangers began to attack with a bevy of chances. It just so happened that Ducks goaltender, Gibson, was up to the task with a multitude of saves. Even when the Rangers did have him beat, they either rang it off the post/crossbar or missed the net completely.  

Their spirited play did pay off, though, when for the 2nd time in two games, Braden Schneider came through with a big goal near the end of the middle period. It was a blue-line shot very similar to the goal he had in LA, and it found its way past Gibson to cut the lead to 3-2. It was a tally that seemed to give a spark of hope that the 3rd period would provide the Rangers with the time they needed to find their scoring acumen. 

However, that did not turn out to be the case. While the Rangers pretty much dominated most of the period, they either couldn’t finish or solve Gibson (depending on your point of view), and that dreaded term “puck luck” was nowhere to be found. Their two best chances to find the tying goal in the period only highlighted both those entities. 

For the 2nd time in two games, Kaapo Kakko was stopped on a breakaway after a perfect pass from Trouba.  Then at the end of the period, when the Rangers were putting on heavy pressure, Artemi Panarin threw a shot on net that was tipped almost perfectly but hit the crossbar. The puck fell beautifully just to the side of the crease where Trocheck resided, but he was unable to put it into the empty net before a defender impeded his try.  

All this led to a defeat at the end of a western road trip that had a chance to be wildly successful but instead ended on a sour note to an inferior team. 

The NY Rangers now come home with 24 points in 21 games. They do currently sit in a wild card spot. If you adopt the league-wide mentality that Thanksgiving break is the first true milestone to see where your team stands, then their current position is still somewhat favorable. 

However, last night’s loss spotlights that the team still has work to do to become the consistent offensive force that their personnel reflects. Going forward, it will be the difference between fighting for a playoff spot or rising to the top of the division to meet the raised expectations many had coming into the season. 

In this week's episode we discuss NYR's playoff hopes, Quick's extension, Kreider, etc.How to support us and our sponsors:Columbia Sports ApparelESPN+ SubscriptionFanaticsDraft Kings – CODE ITRThanks for listening! Please rate and review our show on your favorite listening platform. Check out our partner's website at www.insidetherink.com for all your latest hockey news.
  1. 68 Down & We Needed This 1
  2. Dead at the Deadline
  3. Somebody Kaliyev Me Please
  4. 4 Nations Break
  5. Too Good to Tank, Too Bad to Rank

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Marc Panzer

NYR Fan living in Long Island

Leave a Reply

Adam Proteau

Catching up With Adam Proteau of The Hockey News

With the trade deadline behind us and teams pushing toward the Stanley Cup playoffs, I figured now was as good a time as ever to conduct an email interview with the great Adam Proteau of The Hockey News. Adam was kind enough to take time out of his busy writing schedule to give us his […]

Read More
Todd McLellan behind the bench

March Contiues to Be a Month That Sinks the Detroit Red Wings Playoff Hopes

March has been the part of the NHL schedule that has caused the Detroit Red Wings the most trouble in the past three seasons. In two of these three seasons, the Red Wings were led by former head coach Derek Lalonde. The Red Wings had a record of 3-11 in March of 2024 under Lalonde. […]

Read More
New Jersey Devils defenseman Luke Hughes celebrates a first-period goal against the Minnesota Wild.

New Jersey Devils Take Down Wild in a Shootout to Sweep the Season Series

The New Jersey Devils defeated the Minnesota Wild 3-2 in a shootout on Monday night at the Prudential Center, sweeping the home-and-home season series between the two. Looking to end a three-game winless streak at home, the Devils put together another 60-plus minute effort that earned them a resilient and well-deserved win over a team […]

Read More