Opinion: NHL Wise Not To Expand Playoff Format

Alex Ovechkin and Charlie Lindgren
AP Press

Ironically, the NHL’s most intriguing week came side by side with the NBA’s “play in” games, which help determine which bubble teams will qualify for the playoffs. Simply win, and you’re in. An excellent idea to drive merchandise, gate sales, and keep your telecom companies happy.

Be that as it may, extending an olive branch to teams who struggled to prove worthy of playoff qualification throughout the regular season is more gimmick than entertainment. Something the NHL would be wise in avoiding.

Yet playoff expansion has been whispered in NHL circles but currently lacks momentum “the last time we polled the general managers on this, which was only two years ago, two-thirds of them favored keeping the playoff system the way it is,” said NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly. Which is refreshing to hear because a vote for extended playoffs is a vote for mediocrity. Case and point this year’s Eastern Conference.

Granted, the five-horse race for playoff positioning between the Pittsburgh Penguins, Philadelphia Flyers, Washington Capitals, Detroit Red Wings, and New York Islanders has been wildly entertaining. Due primarily to how pathetic the participants played.

In March, the aforementioned teams combined for 46 losses and 27 wins. Washington led the pack with nine victories; the Islanders got six, while Pittsburgh (11), Detroit (11), and Philadelphia (10) suffered double-digit losses. It is at this point I feel obligated to remind the reader these are bubble teams in fierce competition for the playoffs.

April flipped the script. There were 22 combined victories, with the Islanders (7) moving up and securing the third Metropolitan Division playoff spot. On April 16th, the Penguins, Red Wings, and Flyers were now nipping at the second Wild Card, owning Washington’s heels with one game apiece remaining.

All eyes were fixed to a night where Detroit desperately needed a victory against the Montreal Canadiens. Washington matched up against the Flyers in Philadelphia, looking to strike the proverbial nail in the coffin. While Pittsburgh was helplessly scoreboard-watching.

To recap, here is how things went down:

Appointment-television has become a foreign concept to many but Tuesday night was precisely that. Three minutes separated Detroit, earning a single point to keep their playoff hopes alive at 9:33 ET. To T.J. Oshie breaking a 1-1 tie with an empty net goal at 9:36 ET because Flyer coach John Tortorella, assuming his team needed a regulation win to vault Detroit, was unaware Detroit forcing overtime mathematically eliminated his team.

Entertainment lacking any sense of tribal allegiance. All of which was possible by playing out the remainder of your schedule. No need for pre-determined matchups billed as “win, and you’re in.” 

Now, one can argue consecutive seasons without Sidney Crosby in the playoffs is unfortunate, especially so when the margin of disqualification was less than a handful of points. The Flyers, who over-performed but struggled to maintain momentum, suffered a similar fate. Finally, Detroit still has yet to host a playoff game at Little Caesars Arena, which opened in 2017. The team finishes its season with the same number of points as Washington but with fewer regulation victories, losing the tiebreaker.

We all agree that missing out on a postseason run by a hair-thin margin is unfortunate.

Fact of the matter is 50% of the league makes the playoffs. Lowering the bar dilutes the best playoff product of all four major professional leagues. If you’re skilled enough, healthy enough, and deep enough, you will overcome the challenges presented during an 82-game regular season. There is no need for single elimination or wild cards. You either are or are not. 

On its own, the NHL certainly could benefit from a few adjustments. But when it comes to the postseason and the product on display, there is no need for changes. 

ITR 37: Round Two Inside The Rink

Join Chris and Conrad as they see how they did on their first round predictions, along with laying out their second round thoughts. Picking winners for Round Two!
  1. ITR 37: Round Two
  2. ITR 36: Coaching Carousel
  3. ITR 35: Round One
  4. ITR 34: End Of The Road
  5. ITR 33: The Gr8 One

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

2025 IIHF Worlds: Beniers, Daccord Shine as USA Shuts Out Denmark

Team USA opened their 2025 IIHF Men’s World Championship campaign on Friday afternoon with a convincing matchup against host Denmark in Group B play. With a roster stacked with young NHL talent and a clear commitment to speed and puck possession, the Americans were looking to set the tone early in their pursuit of gold. […]

Read More

2025 IIHF Worlds: Crosby Named Captain of Team Canada

Sidney Crosby of the Pittsburgh Penguins will once again lead Team Canada on the international stage, named captain for the 2025 IIHF Men’s World Championship in Sweden and Denmark. He’ll be joined by alternate captains Nathan MacKinnon of the Colorado Avalanche and Ryan O’Reilly of the Nashville Predators, forming a veteran leadership group with deep […]

Read More
Rick Tocchet behind the bench for the Vancouver Canucks

Boston Bruins Have a Top Head Coaching Target

You can add Rick Tocchet’s name to the rumor mill when it comes to who the next head coach of the Boston Bruins will be. Tocchet played 47 games for the Bruins from 1996 to 1997 and scored 32 goals for them. Sources say that Tocchet could be a top target for the Bruins to […]

Read More