OPINION: The NHL Picks an Embarrassing Hill to Die On

Shell Shock Designs/Instagram

Tonight is Native American Heritage Night for the Minnesota Wild. Marc-Andre Fleury had a special mask designed by artist Cole Redhorse Taylor to honor his wife Veronique, who is native. But the NHL, in an incredibly embarrassing move, told him that he cannot wear it, even just for warm-ups. At first, Fleury considered wearing it regardless and simply paying the fine. But the NHL took things one step further and threatened the team not once but twice with a large fine. Fleury isn’t even starting tonight. He only wanted it for warm-ups.

The NHL clarified just last month that on-ice player uniforms and gear cannot be altered to reflect theme nights. But then why is Sergei Bobrovsky allowed to wear a Hockey Fights Cancer mask? Is it because he’s been using it as a regular helmet instead of for just one night? Or was Native American Heritage considered controversial while cancer is not?

This all stemmed from Pride Nights last year and the controversy over the warm-up jerseys and using Pride Tape. Without delving too deep into that conversation (which is important, but is a discussion for another day), it’s important to remember that the NHL claims that they are working on inclusion in the game of hockey. Hockey is for Everyone; it shouldn’t be just a catchphrase. 

Marc-Andre Fleury is one of the most well-respected players in the league. He’s a future Hall-of-Famer. He’s arguably the most well-liked player in the sport of hockey today. He helped design a helmet that not only celebrates his wife’s ancestry but also his children and father. The league feels so strongly that they threatened Fleury and the Wild team multiple times about wearing it. And Fleury, being the nice guy that he is, doesn’t want to put anyone in a bad spot.

What controversial cause would Fleury be pushing by wearing this mask? Supporting indigenous communities? Celebrating indigenous ancestry and families? Does the NHL realize that the message they are sending? It doesn’t sound much like “Don’t wear special gear” as much as it sounds like “We do not support marginalized communities in this sport.”

So what can the NHL do? There would be better policies to put in place to let players support theme nights. While they have thankfully reversed the ban on Pride Tape, they should clarify other issues. Could players wear a baseball hat themed for a night during warm-ups? Can goalies design and wear masks that they design and pay for? At what point will players be able to express themselves through their gear? The NHL can sell helmet space for ads. 

The idea of banning specialty jerseys was to allow players freedom of speech, correct? Players wanted to be able to choose whether they participated or not. But there are plenty of goalie masks in regular rotation that contain religious or political symbols. As long as they don’t contain anything hateful, that’s fine. 

So why did the NHL pick this as their hill to die on? They must’ve realized the optics of this, right? Telling the most respected player in the league that wearing a non-political mask honoring his wife and children’s heritage just for warm-ups isn’t alright. And they didn’t just warn him once, but up to three times. Even one step further from that, the Wild have an Indigenous player. Connor Dewar is of Red River Metis heritage and very proud of it. He was even honored last summer for his dedication to his community.

The NHL shows once again that they think Hockey is for Everyone (who is white and male).

Throwing Walleye and Dented Jock Straps Her Wild Side Hockey Podcast

The pod is back! The hockey world has been all a tizzy the past 24 hours, so Mikki is back to discuss. From the fish-tossing debate with the Seattle Kraken and Auston Matthews's mysterious trip to Germany to Nashville's bench minor and Zuccarello's unfortunate injury, there is plenty to talk about.Links:Her Wild Side Merch Shop!Ticketmaster Affiliate LinkSocial Media:TwitterInstagramFacebookFor more from us, visit Inside The RinkHow to support us and our sponsors:Columbia Sports ApparelESPN+ SubscriptionFanaticsDraft Kings – CODE ITR  
  1. Throwing Walleye and Dented Jock Straps
  2. Zuccarello's All-Star Game and the McDavid Wedding
  3. Let's Talk About Brock Faber's Contract Extension
  4. Summer Hockey and Why Minnesota Is the State of Hockey
  5. PWHL Minnesota is a Mess. Can It Be Saved?

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

ECHL North Division Finals – Game 3 Recap: Trois-Rivieres Lions vs Norfolk Admirals

On Thursday night, the North Division Finals shifted to Norfolk, Virginia. The two teams split the first two games in TR. Norfolk would make a change in net as they went with Domenic DiVicentiis. The 21-year-old goaltender also started Game 3 of the North Division Semifinals, making 29 saves in a win. In game 2 […]

Read More
Mikko Rantanen skating for the Dallas Stars

Opinion: Stars’ Mikko Rantanen Returns to Form At the Right Time

It was clear that Mikko Rantanen was not exactly about being traded by the Colorado Avalanche, the only NHL club he had ever known. It was in Colorado where he spent close to 11 seasons, won a Stanley Cup in 2022, had 681 points (287 goals and 394 assists), and made lifelong friends. That is […]

Read More

Edmonton Oilers Playoff Thoughts: Round 2, Game 2

It takes four wins to advance, but the Edmonton Oilers historically lose almost every Game 1. In their last 15 rounds, including Tuesday night, they’ve won only four series openers. Even in 2006, they only won one Game 1. If you include that Playoff run, just for laughs, the record is 5 Game 1 wins […]

Read More