Opinion: The Oilers Defence is a Mess…Again

THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck

All offseason, we heard the same old story from the Oilers organization. “We learned lessons”. “Defence is a priority”. But after two embarrassing losses to the Vancouver Canucks, the Oilers are back at square one. What’s wrong? Let’s break it down. And offer a solution at the end, specifically meant for the ears of Ken Holland.

Systemic Failure

Jay Woodcroft stressed all offseason that he was making defensive adjustments and implementing them during training camp. So what has this system brought? So far, extra goals for their opponents. From watching them play, it seems like the Oilers want to play a zone defense. And that’s fine. If players have high enough hockey IQs, they can understand where to be in their zones and when to pick up a specific player. But the Oilers don’t have that luxury. Their players are simply too obsessed with offense. They consistently play the offensive side of the puck and look to break out before they even have possession. This leads to goals like Brock Boeser’s snapshot snipe in the season opener. The centre abandoned his zone to assist Cody Cecil in the corner. That’s okay if they play the defensive side. But they attack from behind, attempting to get a quick steal. Meanwhile, Darnell Nurse is puck-watching. He is waiting for the puck to squeak out so he can start the rush-up ice. However, he had wandered too close to the side of the net. This left a massive hole for Boeser to sneak into. And he made no mistake. Woodcroft has to drill this into his players. Defensive. Side. Of. The. Puck. Speaking of his players…

Personnel

Defensemen need to play defence. It’s that simple. But through his team building, Ken Holland has decided that his defensemen should be glorified forwards. Now, I’m not saying a team can’t benefit from some backend offence. But there should be one, maybe two, defensemen like that on a team. Defensemen are there to break the puck out and keep it out of the net. Nurse, Ceci, Evan Bouchard, and Philip Broberg are all offence first defensemen. They play on the offensive side of the puck more often than not and simply put pinch too much. How many times have you seen two defensemen down low in the O-zone in an Oilers game? I can tell you. Many times. This offseason needed another new face on the back end. But instead of clearing space for another Ekholm-style move, they signed Connor Brown. Another scoring forward. Edmonton simply doesn’t have a championship D-core. So what’s the fix?

A Solution

I have looked over the Oilers cap situation (which is a story for another time), and I have one solution. Ken Holland needs to come to terms with the fact that one of his star wingers needs to go. Edmonton simply has too much money invested in the top six. Personally, I would trade Ryan Nugent-Hopkins. His value is as high as it will ever be after a career year, so teams looking for that missing offensive piece will be eager to get in on a forward like that. I know he is a fan favourite, but hard decisions have to be made to win. After that trade, I would take whatever assets acquired from it and tack on some of their own. Maybe Xavier Bourgault and a first. Then I would call a team like Washington, who are frankly on the downturn, and give them a massive haul for a defence man like John Carlson. A true number one. A minute muncher who can break a puck out and play safe and secure on both ends of the ice. Other options to look at could include Adam Pelech and hometown kid Colton Parayko. Overall, there just needs to be a personnel change. Holland needs to accept that.

ITR 47: Then There Was Nothing Inside The Rink

Join Conrad and Chris as the discuss Gavin McKenna making the jump to the NCAA, Pittsburgh and San Jose making additions, and the NHL season to begin on October 7, 2025.
  1. ITR 47: Then There Was Nothing
  2. ITR 46: Offseason Chaos
  3. ITR 45: Everything Is Happening
  4. ITR 44: We Have A Champion…Again
  5. ITR 43: It's Winning Time

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 thoughts on “Opinion: The Oilers Defence is a Mess…Again

Leave a Reply

NHL Game Preview: Montreal Canadiens at Detroit Red Wings with Line Combinations 12/21/2024

Opinion: The Red Wings are Closer than You Think

By the time it was over, the 2023-24 season gave little hope to Red Wings fans. Montreal, Columbus and Ottawa all passed them in points this season, both Ottawa and Montreal broke the playoff barrier and ended their droughts. Fans and media alike deemed this offseason as one where the Red Wings needed to make […]

Read More
Ben Scrivens of the Edmonton Oilers

Ghosts Of Oilers Past: Ben Scrivens

With goaltending becoming a more humongous topic among Oilers fans than it already was prior to this season, why not have some fun and reminisce about one of the very few good highlights during the Decade of Darkness? The most historic performance by a goalie in the regular season happened on a team that, at […]

Read More
Utah Mammoth

Utah Mammoth 2025-26 Games To Watch

Year two of the Utah hockey experience begins in mere months, and the schedule is full of games from Central Division faceoffs to meetings with back-to-back Stanley Cup Champions and even rebuilding Eastern Conference contenders. NOV. 12th – vs Buffalo Sabres Easily able to be described as the biggest offseason move General Manager Bill Armstrong […]

Read More