Should The Edmonton Oilers Pursue Anthony Mantha?

Photo: NBC Sports

On a recent episode of the 32 Thoughts podcast, Elliotte Friedman entertained the idea of the Edmonton Oilers making a trade with the Washington Capitals for forward Anthony Mantha.

He sighted Ken Holland’s history with Mantha, selecting him 20th overall in the 2013 NHL Draft when he was the general manager of the Detroit Red Wings. Of course, there’d have to be at least one Detroit reference regarding Holland inching closer to the Trade Deadline. But does Mantha make sense for Edmonton? Through 53 games in his 9th NHL season, he has 18 goals and 13 assists for 31 points. He’s played 473 games throughout the entirety of his career and has 283 points.

Related Post: Could the Oilers Switch Kulak For Broberg?

As far as offensive production goes, he would help with secondary scoring on either the second or third line. That has been an issue for the Oilers after the All-Star break, and seeing the line blender come back has been an eye-roll. There’s only one gripe about his game that I’ll nitpick. Despite being 6’5″ and weighing 234 lbs., he doesn’t throw as many hits as he probably should. He has 30 this season, with his highest total being 91 in the 2017/2018 season. Granted, his current team has played a few less games than Edmonton. But even some Oilers players who don’t come with as much size or who aren’t associated with playing a gritty game have more hits. I’m not saying that it’s everything to bruise your opponents; it just doesn’t hurt to have that aspect in a 7 game series when the games get tougher and more intense. The other red flag is his $5.7M cap hit, albeit expiring in the offseason, but this is always going to be something to deal with when you’re trying to make a deep Playoff run.

Are you interested in Anthony Mantha? Are you not? Let me know.


Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Stephen Vani

Oilers fan in Toronto. Staying up past my bedtime for Western games since the mid 2000s.

Leave a Reply

NHL Game Preview: Montreal Canadiens at Detroit Red Wings with Line Combinations 12/21/2024

Opinion: The Red Wings are Closer than You Think

By the time it was over, the 2023-24 season gave little hope to Red Wings fans. Montreal, Columbus and Ottawa all passed them in points this season, both Ottawa and Montreal broke the playoff barrier and ended their droughts. Fans and media alike deemed this offseason as one where the Red Wings needed to make […]

Read More
Ben Scrivens of the Edmonton Oilers

Ghosts Of Oilers Past: Ben Scrivens

With goaltending becoming a more humongous topic among Oilers fans than it already was prior to this season, why not have some fun and reminisce about one of the very few good highlights during the Decade of Darkness? The most historic performance by a goalie in the regular season happened on a team that, at […]

Read More
Utah Mammoth

Utah Mammoth 2025-26 Games To Watch

Year two of the Utah hockey experience begins in mere months, and the schedule is full of games from Central Division faceoffs to meetings with back-to-back Stanley Cup Champions and even rebuilding Eastern Conference contenders. NOV. 12th – vs Buffalo Sabres Easily able to be described as the biggest offseason move General Manager Bill Armstrong […]

Read More