What Would a T.J. Brodie Buyout Look Like?

Maple Leafs Defenseman T.J. Brodie Leading the Rush Vs. Senators
Maple Leafs Defenseman T.J. Brodie Leading the Rush Vs. Senators Photo Credit: Richard A. Whittaker / Getty Images

The Toronto Maple Leafs are going to look a lot different next season, despite being expected to keep the core around. After moving on from ex-General Manager Kyle Dubas a few months ago, a new philosophy has been installed with the hiring of Brad Treliving. 

With a new General Manager in place, a lot could change. So far, since Brad was hired, many fans are calling for the current crop of defensemen to be tinkered with, leading to some interesting ideas. Some ideas are valid, whether that’s through trade or signings, but there are also ideas that just shouldn’t even be considered. 

There’s been a lot of smoke lately in Leaf Land about a potential buyout for defenseman T.J. Brodie. After being one of the best defensive-defenseman all season long, a rougher postseason than expected has really affected how some view the player. 

The 33-year-old defenseman is a large piece of the current Maple Leafs blueline, primarily playing in a shutdown role which he’s excelled at. Going into the last season of his deal, T.J. Brodie’s cap hit for 2023-24 is $5,000,000 with a base salary of $7,500,000 and comes with a minimal no-trade clause. Given his role and versatility, moving on without a steady replacement can be a serious gamble.

The Toronto Maple Leafs should not entertain the thought of buying out defenseman T.J. Brodie, but if they did, here’s what it would look like according to Capfriendly.com’s buyout calculator. 

Buying out the veteran defenseman would cost the Maple Leafs $5,000,000 and save about $2,500,000 given his $7,500,000 salary for next season. How does this help the team? Well, the Maple Leafs would completely clear T.J. Brodie’s $5,000,000 cap hit next season but would be charged $2,500,000 on the team’s cap hit for 2024-25. With the Maple Leafs already so tight against the salary cap, buyout charges can really do some harm. 

With Maple Leafs stars like Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, and William Nylander all in need of extensions, buying out T.J. Brodie doesn’t really make sense. If it did happen, it would only help the Maple Leafs for this upcoming season, limiting the team’s financial space for future seasons. If the Maple Leafs know this could be their last kick at the can with the core, then I could see why, but it’s definitely not something I’m interested in. 

Obviously, this is all rumors, and given the familiarity between T.J. Brodie and Brad Treliving, many have kicked around this idea. I wouldn’t lose any sleep over it just yet until some actual concrete information was made public. Now I can see a trade being possible, and I’m a lot more open to that idea, but as I said earlier, without a steady defensive replacement, that’s a dangerous move and one that could do more harm than good. 

Thanks for reading! For more Leafs content, follow me on Twitter at ITR_Anselmo.

2-0? In THIS Economy? Leafs Late Night

WELCOME BACK TO LEAFS LATE NIGHT! Presented by Inside The RinkRoscoe / Biehner – Shots vs Results- Knock On Wood- Domi's Legacy- Roscoe Rant- Stolarz vs GriegNEW MERCH IS AVAILABLE!JOIN OUR DISCORD!Remember to follow us on Twitter @LeafsLateNight & IG @LeafsLateNightCheck out Mike, Josh, and Nathan's articles on the Leafs + many more! insidetherink.comHow to support us and our sponsors:TicketmasterColumbia Sports ApparelESPN+ SubscriptionFanaticsDraft Kings – CODE ITR
  1. 2-0? In THIS Economy?
  2. The Battle of Ontario: Remastered Edition
  3. Saint Joseph Woll
  4. Vanquishing Rivals of Yesteryear
  5. Lawesome-Tawesome

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Joshua Anselmo

A hockey mind that's always looking at new and insightful ways to bring different perspectives of the game we all love.

Leave a Reply

Edmonton Oilers vs. Vegas Golden Knights

Edmonton Oilers Playoff Thoughts: Round 2 Game 1

Hockey weekends like this past one are always more fun when it’s not your team playing a tight and stressful game. But now it’s time we got back to watching our games. As I’m writing this, the Los Angeles Kings are mutually parting ways with former defenseman and now former GM Rob Blake. I alluded […]

Read More
NHL Draft Lottery

Detroit Red Wings Fall in Draft Lottery Once Again

The NHL Draft Lottery was held last night before game one of the second-round series between the Toronto Maple Leafs and Florida Panthers. The Detroit Red Wings once again fell in the draft, this time to number 13. The New York Islanders will have the first pick in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft, while the […]

Read More
NHL Playoff Preview: Edmonton Oilers at Vegas Golden Knights with Line Combinations 5/5/2025

NHL Playoff Preview: Edmonton Oilers at Vegas Golden Knights with Line Combinations 5/6/2025

NHL Playoff Preview: Edmonton Oilers at Vegas Golden Knights with Line Combinations 5/5/2025

Read More