Will The Penguins Reach the Finish Line on a Karlsson Trade?

Photo Credit: Chris Brown/Zuma

The holidays are over, and I am back to work today. However, the Penguins could still be looking to create a celebration by acquiring defenseman Erik Karlsson from the San Jose Sharks. 

I was listening to the 32 Thoughts podcast yesterday and was intrigued by what Elliotte Friedman said about talks between the Oilers and Sharks on Karlsson around the trade deadline. He mentioned that the Sharks told the Oilers they were willing to eat about 18-20% of his salary. He said that to move Karlsson, the Sharks would likely have to retain close to 40% of his salary instead of 20%, but they can’t do 50%. 

The Sharks likely want to take on around $3 million of Karlsson’s cap. 20% is about $2.3 million, and 35% is over $4 million. 

The Penguins are currently over the salary cap as well, which makes things harder. The Pens will likely have to send as much cap space out as they take in for Karlsson. Although the Sharks reportedly have an interest in defenseman Jeff Petry, and trading him would make a LOT of sense, he does have a 15-team no-trade clause. He also wouldn’t make sense in San Jose, in my opinion as well. Making this trade a three-team trade would make the most sense, in my opinion. 

A trade could start with moving defenseman Jan Rutta, forward Mikael Granlund, and goaltender Casey DeSmith. Also, Friedman also mentioned that the Pens don’t want to trade defenseman Marcus Pettersson this summer. I smiled when I heard that. 

Either way, the goal of Dubas right now seems to be wanting to bring Karlsson to Pittsburgh. However, Karlsson does have full control with a complete no-movement clause. If the Penguins can make this extremely complicated trade work, with three teams and several players being moved, it would be something to see. 


Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Nik Shermeto

PT ‘23 | 🇺🇸/🇨🇦 | Penguins writer for Inside The Rink | Thoughts are my own.

Leave a Reply

2025 IIHF Worlds: United States Edges Norway 6-5 in a Wild Comeback Battle

In a heart-pounding clash at the 2025 IIHF World Championship, the United States secured a 6-5 overtime victory over Norway, with Tage Thompson delivering a dramatic hat trick, including the game-winning goal. After building a commanding 5-1 lead, the U.S. saw Norway mount an incredible comeback, forcing a tense overtime period. Stian Solberg’s three-goal performance […]

Read More

Edmonton Oilers Playoff Thoughts: Round 2, Game 5

“I decided to play this position, so it’s completely my fault” – Stuart Skinner after the Edmonton Oilers Game 4 Nobody needed Monday night’s win more than the guy between the pipes. If you’re an Edmonton Oilers fan on social media, you know what I’m talking about. If you don’t use social media apps, bless […]

Read More

2024-25 Inside The Rink NHL Awards

The 2024-25 NHL Season is all wrapped up, and we at Inside The Rink surveyed several writers on who they think should win each NHL award. Each winner of the Inside The Rink awards will be bolded and italicized. Hart Memorial Trophy (Most Valuable Player) Connor Hellebuyck (WPG) 8 votes (61.5%)Leon Draisaitl (EDM) 1 vote […]

Read More