The Scouting Report
Defenseman Carter Yakemchuk is one of the better two-way defensemen in the 2024 NHL Draft. At 6’3″ and 194 pounds, he has the size to be effective in the defensive zone yet is mobile enough to be productive on the offensive end. He increased his draft stock during the 2023-24 season with the Calgary Hitmen of the Western Hockey League (WHL). He raised his goal total from 19 to 30, his assists from 28 to 41, and his overall point total from 47 to 71 in two seasons. Last season, he led WHL defensemen in goals with 30, showing he is capable of leading an offense. His overall game needs some work, but he is a top-tier talent among defensemen.
View All 2024 NHL Draft Profiles Here
Draft Projections
Ranked #24 by DOBBERPROSPECTS
Ranked #18 by ELITEPROSPECTS.COM
Ranked #11 by TSN/ CRAIG BUTTON
Ranked #13 by DAILY FACEOFF
Ranked #11 by NHL CENTRAL SCOUTING (NA SKATERS)
I’ve highlighted some of Carter Yakemchuk’s attributes. Let’s take a deeper dive into his attributes and areas for improvement
Diving Deeper
Despite being one of the older players in the draft, he comes with an array of tools in his skill set. Offensively, he is as gifted as any and plays like a fourth forward. On defense, he hits like a truck and plays positionally sound hockey. He is a force on the power play and effective in closing gaps on the penalty kill. A player of many talents.
“With good size, deft puck handles and a wicked shot, he resembles a skilled power forward. Instead, he’s an high-end offensive defenceman.”- Sam Cosentino- Sportsnet- March 13th
Attribute One
Yakemchuk is one of the better skating defensemen that could go in the top 10-15 picks. He is not Paul Coffey but he can take the puck end-to-end and skate the puck out of trouble. If there is a turnover, he can make it back into position on defense with no issues. He is good on his edges, which makes him a better skater with a long stride. He is not a flawless skater but he can out skate some forwards.
“I had my doubts heading into the season, but they’re mostly erased now. The 6-foot-3 defenseman is so smart, he’s an excellent skater and he has tremendous offensive instincts.”- Steven Ellis- Daily Faceoff- March 9th
Attribute Two
Yakemchuk is most effective on the power play as he can find seems through traffic. His shot cannot only find its way past the goaltender on a one-timer but his shot can also be deflected and chased for rebounds as his shot is only inches off the ice. He is a great passer on the man advantage and finds the open man with ease. A great puck handler who can keep the puck in the zone with his long reach. He has a great fake shot that opposing forwards bite on, opening space for his cannon of a shot. Smooth operator at the point, and patient with the puck.
Areas for Improvement
Yakemchuk can improve his hockey IQ. He tends to take too many chances offensively, leaving the team at a disadvantage. Although he is defensively responsible, he puts his offensive game before his defensive game. He also can miss a play, unable to recognize the play before it begins.
“One of the oldest players in the draft class, Yakemchuk has a highlight reel that’s a mile long featuring goals and big hits, but it comes with a lot of risk. Yakemchuk is not only one of the highest-scoring defensemen in the draft, but he’s also one of the most penalized.” – Rachel Doerrie- ESPN- April 2nd
Yakemchuk is an offensive-minded defenseman and it costs him pinching in the offensive zone as this leads to penalties. He needs to work on taking fewer penalties because this has resulted in goals against the Hitmen. He is one of the WHL’s most penalized players (120 in 2023-24) and has taken bad penalties at bad times. Some of these penalty minutes is caused by fatigue due to his minutes played.
Prospect Potential
Yakemchuk has the potential to be a top-pairing defenseman on any team if he cuts down the time in the penalty box. He can also be a quarterback on the first power play unit as he has done a lot of damage from that spot. When he does make the NHL, expect him to be a point-every-other-game type of player, getting 40-45 points a season with the occasional 50-point season.
Beast Potential Fit
With his draft stock high, he could go anywhere from #4-#16. At the #6 spot, Utah will be picking and they could use a franchise defenseman to build around and he could fit in well. At #9, the Calgary Flames could use a point-producing defenseman to operate while the team finds its identity. At #11, the Buffalo Sabres may take him if he is still there. Buffalo already has Owen Power and Rasmus Dahlin but they are left-handed shots. He could be part of a talented Sabres team that leads them to a playoff spot.
Final Thought
For Yakemchuk to be successful at the next level, he needs to cut down on the penalty minutes and concentrate more on the defensive side to round out his overall game. He has the potential to be a well-rounded defenseman who could be a star in the league. He could be anywhere from a bottom-pairing defenseman if he does not clean up his game to an all-star defenseman if he does.
