Kane or Giroux – Which move makes the most sense for the Oilers?

Ken Holland has some big decisions ahead of him, with free agency looming and several necessary roster moves on the agenda. One of those moves will be figuring out what to do with Evander Kane.

The Oilers signed Kane to a “show me” deal for one year at $2m last winter, and he passed the test with flying colours, scoring at a 40-goal pace and leading the team in playoff goals. Kane’s play has allowed him and his agent, Dan Milstein, to get bold with their asking price in free agency.

It has been reported that Kane is seeking upwards of $7m AAV on a six or seven-year contract. This would last until Kane hits his mid-to-late 30s on an expensive deal that the Oilers will have a tough time fitting in.

Thanks to the offloading of Zack Kassian’s contract, Duncan Keith’s retirement, and Mike Smith’s move onto LTIR, the Oilers have about $20m in cap space, with RFAs Kailer Yamamoto, Ryan McLeod, and Jesse Puljujarvi needing new contracts.

In addition, the Oilers must sign a starting goaltender (Jack Campbell and Darcy Kuemper seem to be the most ideal fits). They also must find a replacement for Duncan Keith (Kulak is a potential option to return in a more prominent role), and of course, they have to acquire a top-six forward, whether Kane or someone cheaper.

Evander Kane’s Goals Above Replacement Models for 2019-2022 via Evolving hockey

Elliotte Freidman reported on his 32 thoughts podcast that the Oilers have expressed interest in free agent Claude Giroux. It is doubtful that Giroux will command the type of salary that Kane is, and the term would likely be less as well. There are pros and cons to this option.

One issue about replacing Kane with Giroux is that he doesn’t provide the same goal-scoring prowess as Kane. While his playmaking and overall offensive production are still at around a point per game level, he isn’t an elite finisher, which is ideal next to Connor McDavid, as we saw with Kane this spring. Giroux also doesn’t have that physical edge to his game that Kane does either, and that will no doubt be missed with the departure of Kassian.

With all of this being said, there are some serious upsides to going in this direction, in my opinion. If Giroux can be signed for around $5m AAV, the deal would open up about an extra $2m in cap space that they wouldn’t otherwise have. This could help the Oilers acquire another defenseman to take the heat off Brett Kulak on the left side, or they could use it to sign a middle-six forward to replace Jesse Puljujarvi, who it appears is almost certainly on the way out of Edmonton.

While Claude Giroux doesn’t possess Kane’s physicality, he has a long track record of elite two-way play, and the Oilers sorely need players that can play solid team defense come playoff time. Another plus is that Giroux will come in on a much shorter-term deal. He is four years older than Kane, and I can see him signing on a 3-4 year deal instead of 6 or 7. And, of course, there are the off-ice concerns with Kane and whether or not he can maintain good behavior moving forward.

Claude Giroux’s GAR card for 2019-2022 via Evolving Hockey

Ultimately, the question comes down to this: Would you rather have Kane for about 7$m AAV on a 6-7 year deal or Giroux for around $5m on a 3-4 year deal with extra money to bring in a D-man, or forward? Will Claude Giroux’s reliably good underlying numbers falter as he ages? Or will he continue achieving positive results for the next few years? The correct answer to this puzzle may lie with sustainability.

And can Kane maintain his hot shooting and good behavior over the long term despite some concerning underlying numbers and a history of off-ice issues suggesting otherwise? It is an exciting set of questions that Ken Holland will need to make a bet on over the next week or so.

Stanley Cup Aspirations Cue’ the Duck Boats Pod

The boys are back after a long break but have plenty to talk about as the playoffs are in full swing. We go series by series, looking at how teams have fared so far and who will come out on top. Thanks for listening! Please rate and review our show on your favorite listening platform. Check out our partner's website at www.insidetherink.com for all your latest hockey news.
  1. Stanley Cup Aspirations
  2. The Final Countdown
  3. Here Come the Playoffs
  4. Home Stretch
  5. Kevy Cooks

Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Lane Golden

Born and raised in Edmonton, Alberta, Lane is a passionate sports fan who uses an analytical lens to break down and discuss what is going on in the hockey world.

Leave a Reply

Tanner Jeannot of the Los Angeles Kings

Player Profile: Tanner Jeannot

Tanner Jeannot was born on May 29, 1997, in Estevan, Saskatchewan. The left-shooting forward played for three seasons with the Estevan Bruins from 2010-13. In his first two seasons with the U15 club, Jeannot scored 29 goals and collected 18 assists in 42 games and five goals and three assists in ten postseason games. Jeannot […]

Read More
Gage Goncalves of the Tampa Bay Lightning

Tampa Bay Lightning Make Significant Player Signings To Start July

As free agency has started in the National Hockey League, many teams, including the Tampa Bay Lightning, are making significant roster moves with free agents and player extensions. Just yesterday, July 1, for day one of free agency, the Lightning extended young 24-year-old Portuguese forward Gage Goncalves to a two-year contract worth $1.2 million a […]

Read More
William Moore 2025 Draft Profile

Breaking Down Boston Bruins General Manager Don Sweeney’s Draft

Boston Bruins General Manager Don Sweeney has been in his position for ten years now and has seen success with one Stanley Cup Finals appearance and one historic regular season. This past season was the first time since 2016 that the Bruins failed to make the playoffs. Sweeney has added pieces to the prior core […]

Read More