Opinion: Why Auston Matthews Can Finish His Career Top Five of the NHL’s All-Time Scoring List

Auston Matthews is about seventy percent of the way through his seventh season as a Maple Leaf, and his goal-scoring prowess is astounding and constantly improving each time he hits the ice.

He scored 40 goals in his rookie season and still hasn’t slowed down. If we create a hypothetical scenario where Matthews plays just as long as Alex Ovechkin, he would be on pace for at least 830 goals by the time he is 36 years old if he continues to have 50-goal seasons.

However, Matthews has been stumped by injuries throughout his six years in the league. He has only had two seasons in which he has played at least 70 games. 

Along with that, the COVID-19 pandemic forced the NHL to adapt their season in 2020. There were only 52 regular-season games, and he still managed to put up 40 goals.

In March of the 2021-22 season, he has a league-leading 46 goals, with twenty-five games still to go. Matthews is on pace to finish the regular season with 66 goals.

That would be the highest tally for a season since, guess who, Alex Ovechkin in 2007-08. If he stays healthy and consistent, he could raise the standards for goal scoring for years to come.

Toronto needs him out on the ice every night. If he can manage to play seventy to eighty games per season for the rest of his career, he has a chance to do it.

There’s so much time left in his career and a lot of hockey to play, so this is all just hypothetical fun. 

But, if this is something that should be seriously considered, the Leafs need to start winning playoff series. Matthews is missing out on up to 28 games in the playoffs to score goals.

Since being drafted, Matthews has not experienced playoff hockey past the first round. 

With all those extra games, he is sure to test the top 10 list. Because he is so young and already arguably the best goalscorer in the league, his yearly tallies will only go up if he continues to play most of the season.

Predicted goal tally: 780 goals


Discover more from Inside The Rink

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

IIHF U18: USA Rallies in the Third to Defeat Czechia 4–2

Team USA stormed back in the third period to earn a thrilling 4–2 victory over Czechia at the 2025 IIHF U18 Men’s World Championship, erasing a late deficit with three unanswered goals. The win showcased the Americans’ grit, depth, and late-game execution in a high-stakes Men’s Worlds matchup. Goals from Blake Fiddler, Will Horcoff, and […]

Read More
Chris Drury, General Manager of the New York Rangers

Opinion: Why Did The Rangers Decide to Extend Chris Drury?

There were many things wrong with the New York Rangers this season. For starters, they failed to make the Stanley Cup playoffs this season after winning the Presidents’ Trophy as the NHL’s best team last season. The Blueshirts finished fifth in the Metropolitan Division, 11th in the Eastern Conference, and 22nd in the league with […]

Read More
Brady Tkachuk skating for the Ottawa Senators

NHL Game Preview: Toronto Maple Leafs at Ottawa Senators with Line Combinations 4/24/2025

Game 3: Toronto Maple Leafs (2-0) at Ottawa Senators (0-2)Venue: Canadian Tire CenterDate: Tonight- Thursday, April 24Time: 7:00 pm EST TV: ESPN2, CBC, SportsnetRadio:Toronto – TSN 1050Ottawa – TSN 1200 DraftKings Sportsbook Betting Lines:Toronto +1.5 ML -105Ottawa -1.5 ML -115O/U 5.5 Purchase tickets via Ticketmaster Toronto Maple Leafs News & Notes: The Maple Leafs won […]

Read More