Predicting the Isles Opening Night Lineup

With not much roster turnover since elimination on April 28th at the hands of the Carolina Hurricanes, there will be plenty of familiar faces in the blue and orange when the Islanders take the ice for opening night on October 14th at UBS Arena.

Isles management will stick with their inner belief in this current group in the room and hope for the best in the upcoming season.

A full season of Bo Horvat and Pierre Engvall should have significant impacts on the scoresheet, right? A hope for continued growth from young blue-liners Noah Dobson and Alex Romanov could bring the Islanders back to being a real threat. Will Brock Nelson and Ilya Sorokin regress from their impressive 22-23 campaigns? Will the power play improve? All questions that will be answered throughout the season.

But what will Lane Lambert’s lineup look like on opening night when the Buffalo Sabres come to Elmont?

Let’s take a look.

Line 1:

Anders Lee-Bo Horvat-Mat Barzal

The most probable top line for the Isles consists of the club’s captain and their two best forwards. This line had success when paired together in the regular season. The question will be, can Anders Lee can keep up with the speed of Bo and Barzy?

Line 2:

Pierre Engvall-Brock Nelson-Kyle Palmieri

Without the acquisition of Pierre Engvall before the trading deadline, there’s a real solid shot the Isles will miss the postseason. When this line was paired together, it was pure brilliance. Engvall and Nelson brought out the best hockey Kyle Palmieri has played in quite a long time. Engvall emerged as a legitimate middle six forward, while Brock Nelson was criminally underrated, as per usual. These three should be penciled in together for the 2nd line already.

Line 3:

Simon HolmstromJG Pageau-Oliver Wahlstrom

Now, here is where it get’s a bit complicated. There’s a definitely a scenario where Simon Holmstrom and Oliver Wahlstrom are both not on the opening night roster, whether it’s because of trade or a scratch, but with where the Isles are at, they’re in need of some young legs. Holmstrom’s defensive game is much stronger than that of Wahlstrom’s, making Wahlstrom’s slotting on the 3rd line defensive line a possible mismatch. Pageau can be plugged anywhere in the lineup, so we will see where this goes, but if you’re trying to get your best hockey players as high in the lineup as possible, this is it.

Line 4:

Matt MartinCasey CizikasHudson Fasching

After nearly a decade, the Isles “identity line” is broken up. Hudson Fasching is too good of a player to be kept out of the lineup, and the injury-prone Cal Clutterbuck is sent to the press box.

D-Pair 1:

Adam Pelech-Ryan Pulock

After two seasons of injury riddled hockey, the P and P pair are re-united at full health to return to be one of the top pairings in all of hockey.

D-Pair 2:

Alex Romanov-Noah Dobson

The kids on the back end are brought back together again to start the season. Another year of maturity for both Romanov and Dobson could go a long way in forming a quite balanced 2nd pairing.

D-Pair 3:

Sebastian Aho-Scott Mayfield

The underlining numbers say Sebastian Aho was one of the best d-men in his respective role in all of 22-23. Scott Mayfield was re-signed to a seven-year deal and is just a steady defenseman that can eat up minutes.


Ilya Sorokin

Semyon Varlamov

Obviously, there is zero uncertainty in the blue paint for the foreseeable future for the Isles. Potentially, Varlamov could get some more starts than last season to lighten the load on Sorokin a bit. Sorokin started in 60 games last season and came in relief twice. That’s a lot of pucks at a guy in one season.


Julien Gauthier (RW)

Cal Clutterbuck (RW)

Samuel Bolduc (LD)

Obviously, this is all just a major massive prediction, but this is the best bet of what Lane Lambert’s Isles look like on October 14th. Does this group have enough to reach the postseason? We will find out.

3 thoughts on “Predicting the Isles Opening Night Lineup

  1. Your line up has 32 sent to BPT (I am assuming). If history is a good indicator for future decisions, I don’t see Lou doing it.
    That leaves Holmstrom starting in BPT I would guess. I would prefer your lines to what will probably happen. Keeping Ross to play 20% of the games and less than 10 minutes a game is not a good use of resources but we don’t make the decisions

    1. I expect Johnston to be sent down with his 1.1 million dollar cap hit to get the Isles under the cap.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

An Email Interview with Florida Everblades Broadcaster Jake Maurice

When you grow up in a family that has a member who is involved with hockey or loves the game of hockey, there is always a good chance that you will get involved with the game in some way as well. One such person is Florida Everblades broadcaster Jake Maurice. Jake’s father is Florida Panthers’ […]

Read More

Opinion: Why Nebraska Is An Untapped Expansion Market

With the Arizona Coyotes franchise moving to Utah, plenty of discussions have been sparked about where NHL teams should be located. That coupled with what was a surprise for me personally, NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman stating during the All-Star break that Omaha, Nebraska, had expressed interest in getting an expansion team. That announcement has made […]

Read More

Prospect Profile: Ryan Walsh

Ryan Walsh was born on August 25, 2003, in Rochester, New York. Walsh played for the Rochester Selects 16U AAA team in a Covid-shortened 2019-20 season. In eight games, the center scored three goals with three assists. The next season, on the Rochester Coalition 18U AAA club, Walsh contributed 13 goals and 21 assists in […]

Read More