Top Players For Toronto To Target At The Trade Deadline

Kyle Dubas working the phones on the draft floor

As we inch closer to the trade deadline, there hasn’t been much info coming out about the Leafs’ plans. The 2021-22 iteration of the Leafs is a team with few holes. GM Kyle Dubas did a great job extracting plus value from bargain bin signings. Even still, there is always room for improvement. The two areas that Toronto could feasibly improve are their top 6 left-wingers and the right side of their back end. It just so happens that some of the most exciting names available at this year’s deadline fall under those two categories.


If I’m Toronto’s GM, this is the area I’m most looking to address. We’ve heard lack of grit, leadership, heart, and defense as reasons for the Leafs not advancing past the first round in five straight seasons. But when you look at the numbers, what doomed Toronto in the last two series is clear: offense drying up.

Top-6 LW:

Filip Forsberg: Expiring deal @ $6m, deadline cap hit: ~$1.175m

His name has been floated as a potential Toronto trade target for years now. The problem with that is that Nashville currently sits in 1st in the central division. It seems likely Nashville might want to keep him as a self-rental or sign an extension.

Tomas Hertl: Expiring deal @ $5.6m, deadline cap hit: ~$1.1m

Hertl will be one of the most sought-after players and, as such, will likely cost an arm and a leg. That being said, he should be Toronto’s top priority. He instantly becomes the Buds’ 1LW, their best option to fill in at C in case of a Matthews/Tavares injury, and improves both the PP and PK. Along with great production, his impacts at both ends of the ice paint him as a truly elite 2-way forward. I don’t see anyone else having as much of an impact as Hertl.

Claude Giroux: Expiring deal @ $8.275m, deadline cap hit: ~$1.625m

Reports have started coming out that long-time Flyers captain Claude Giroux will be shipped out of Philly at this year’s deadline. Toronto would be a great landing spot for the veteran leader. Like Hertl, he has excelled at both centre and on the wing over his career. The 33-year-old has shored up his defensive game over the last two seasons without sacrificing any of his offensive play driving. He’s also been a part of some of the best playoff series in recent memory, and that experience could prove invaluable.

JT Miller: 1 year left at $5.25m, deadline cap hit: ~$1.03m

The Leafs would have to move out salary to keep him beyond this season, but he’s the type of player that could make a real difference to a team’s offense in the playoffs. He plays a power game fighting through checks and creating havoc in the OZ with his physicality. His playoff numbers don’t jump off the page, but in his first run as a top-6 forward with Vancouver, he was over a PPG in 17 games. Canucks interim GM Jim Rutherford has said that any moves made would be for draft picks and prospects, and Miller would bring in a nice haul.


Toronto’s defense is much better than people would have you believe. They were 7th in xGA last year and locked it down even more in the playoffs. They are still top 15 despite having two rookies playing significant roles. Adding a top-4 or bottom-6 RHD should still be something they look at. According to NHL insider Chris Johnston, @reporterchris on Twitter, during a TSN 1050 radio hit, that’s where Dubas’ mind is at.


Jakob Chychrun: 3 years left @ $4.6m, deadline cap hit: ~ $900k

Again, the Leafs would likely need to move out salary to fit his cap hit over the next three years, but for a 23-year-old #1D who scores goals and plays a pretty nasty game, you probably don’t mind doing so. Arizona is reportedly asking for an “Eichel-like package” in return, so that might price the Leafs out with their top 2 prospects having hardly played any hockey this year due to injury. Regardless he would be an unreal add to an already good Leafs D core.

Connor Murphy: 4 years left @ $4.4m, deadline cap hit: ~$850k

Another guy that would require some movement to fit the cap hit for the term, Connor Murphy, is currently playing top pair minutes and putting up good defensive results for a lousy team in Chicago. Stan Bowman seemed to think the Blackhawks still had a shot at the cup and re-upped Murphy to a 4-year extension this offseason. If their new GM sees things differently, Dubas might be able to pry Murphy out of there for the right price. The shutdown defenseman would look great on Toronto’s second pair.

Bottom Pair:

Mark Pysyk: Expiring deal @ $900k, deadline hit: ~$175k

Pysyk has put up good play driving and defensive metrics in a depth role over the past three years. If the Leafs are just looking to add a steady NHL-caliber defenseman in case of injury, he would fit that bill.

Luke Schenn: 1 year left @ $850k, deadline hit: ~$165k

A Luke Schenn reunion would certainly add some grit to the bottom pair. The 31-year-old could play a Bogosian-like role for Toronto if they feel Liljegren isn’t ready for NHL playoff hockey.

Trade pieces: 2022 1st rd pick, 2023 draft picks, Robertson, Amirov, Niemela, Knies.

Toronto has traded away a ton of assets in the last few years. Quite a few of their later-round picks have certainly increased their stock post-draft but probably still don’t hold a ton of value in trades. That coupled with their top 2 prospects being injured for the majority of the year, the Leafs don’t have a ton to work with trade-wise. Still, some combination of those mentioned above, plus a roster player or two, should be enough to get a deal done for anyone on this list.

2 thoughts on “Top Players For Toronto To Target At The Trade Deadline

  1. For defense – Pysyk and Colin Miller out of Buffalo may be the cheapest options. klingberg is also out there along with Giordano. For Chykrun I’d add one of Sandin or Liljegren to the deal if needed along with Kerfoot to make the money work.

    Love the idea of Giroux as a pure rental. Major upgrade in top six and would replace Kerfoot should he be traded. Pavelski is also a pure rental idea.

    Leafs will be hard pressed to take on someone with term unless they ship out money. With Kase Mikheyev Sandin Liljegren and Campbell all coming up for renewals there is simply not enough money to go around unless 8-10M is cleared out. That means at min – Ritchie + Mrazek + Holl/Kerfoot.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

IIHF Men’s World Championship Tournament Game Recap: Team USA | 05/16-17/2024

On Thursday, May 16th, the U.S. Men’s National Team was set to compete against France in the fourth preliminary round of the 2024 IIHF Men’s World Championship in Ostrava, Czechia. After a narrow 5-4 overtime loss to Slovakia earlier this week, the U.S. team went into the game looking to rebound from that loss. In […]

Read More

Mike Sullivan selected to lead the U.S. Men’s Team in the 2025 4 Nations Face-Off & 2026 Olympic Winter Games

USA Hockey has named Mike Sullivan, known for leading the Pittsburgh Penguins to two Stanley Cup wins, as the head coach of the U.S. Men’s National Team for the 2025 4 Nations Face-Off and the 2026 Olympic Winter Games. On February 2, the NHL and NHLPA announced the 2025 4 Nations Face-Off event. Set to […]

Read More

Shesterskin Continues to Come Up Big for the Blueshirts

After Thursday night’s thrilling 5-3 victory over the Carolina Hurricanes, all anyone could talk about when it came to the New York Rangers was the outstanding play of Chris Kreider. It was more than well deserved as Kreider, 33, had a game for the ages. With the team down 3-1 going into the third period, […]

Read More